Picture a blustery morning in a small Austrian town: the wind whips around the roof of the house where our traveler’s former love once welcomed him. A weather-vane spins wildly above, and he imagines it mocking him, just as he feels the young woman inside now does. In this short song from Schubert’s Winterreise, the vane becomes a clever symbol of her fickle heart, turning whichever way the social winds blow and leaving the wanderer out in the cold.
As the music unfolds, he realizes painful truths. The proud sign on the family home should have warned him that wealth and status mattered more to them than his devotion. Inside, the wind “plays with their hearts” quietly, suggesting shallow emotions hidden behind polite walls. His question rings out twice: Why should they care about my pain? The answer is as cutting as the winter air—she is already destined to marry a wealthy suitor. The song captures disappointment, irony, and the sting of social divide, setting the stage for the lonely journey that follows in the rest of Schubert’s epic cycle.